Many buyers who took out car finance deals may soon find themselves with an extended opportunity to seek compensation following a significant court ruling that has rendered certain dealership commission practices unlawful. The Court of Appeal recently determined that non-discretionary dealer commissions — payments made to dealers for arranging finance without the buyer’s fully informed consent — are illegal. This landmark decision has sent ripples through the automotive financing industry, akin to the tumult created by the payment protection insurance (PPI) scandal a decade ago.
If you entered into a PCP car finance agreement between 2007 and 2020, you could be affected by this ruling. In light of the judgement, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) is set to issue further guidance by mid-December, which may shape the landscape for prospective claims. Until then, you should remain informed about the developments that may permit you to pursue compensation more effectively.
The case that prompted this ruling involved clients of Close Brothers and Firstrand Bank who asserted that they were mis-sold their finance agreements. After their claims were initially dismissed in lower courts, they successfully appealed to the Court of Appeal, which unanimously agreed that brokers cannot lawfully receive commission payments from lenders without securing the buyer’s unequivocal consent. This decision places additional pressure on dealers, traditionally compensated by banks or lenders for facilitating finance arrangements, to disclose commission rates to their customers fully.
In response to the court’s findings, several car manufacturers have proactively started revealing their commission structures, hoping to maintain operational stability going forward. If you are considering a PCP car finance deal, this transparency may assist you in making more informed decisions about the terms you agree to, particularly regarding any commissions involved.
The ramifications of this ruling are far-reaching, and one of the key players bracing for the impact is Lloyds Bank, which owns Black Horse — a major provider of car financing. Earlier this year, Lloyds disclosed that it had set aside a substantial £450 million to cover legal fees and potential compensation costs arising from this controversy. Your understanding of these financial reserves means that institutions are acknowledging the seriousness of the situation and the financial obligations they may face if many customers step forward with their grievances.
A central aspect of the FCA’s investigation stems from discretionary commission arrangements (DCAs) that allowed dealers and brokers to adjust the interest rates on loans, rewarding themselves with commission payments. A notable case involved a dealer setting the interest rate at 5.5%, which accounted for half of the loan’s total interest. Unbeknownst to you, this rate was artificially inflated to generate a commission without your knowledge of how much was being earned. Such practices highlight the deceptive nature of these agreements and why you might rightfully seek redress.
As the automotive finance industry braces for an influx of complaints and potential lawsuits, it is vital that you remain vigilant and proactive about your rights. If you have taken out a car finance deal in the last several years, this ruling could significantly impact your ability to claim compensation. Be sure to consult with financial experts or legal advisers to explore your options moving forward. Your voice matters, and the recent court ruling may well pave the way for many buyers to finally obtain the justice and compensation they deserve. Find Out If You Have a Claim – Free PCP Check!
Clear Cut Legal specialise in helping drivers uncover mis-sold car finance agreements. If you’ve taken out a PCP or HP finance deal, you could be owed compensation – and we’re here to help.
Our team offers a FREE, no-obligation PCP check to see if you have a valid claim. Don’t miss out on what could be rightfully yours!
Contact us today to get started. Your refund could be just a few steps away!
